Guest Post: How a Community Masjid Can Afford to Provide a Competitive Salary for its Imam

1389176_minaret_at_sunset_1

Guest post by Br. Maher Budeir

In a previous article, “How much should Muslim Clergy be Paid,” brother Omar started a great discussion about the topic. I am one who advocates a similar position, but I would like to carry the conversation beyond defining the issue. We need to start a serious discussion about a framework for solutions. This includes how communities need to be prepared to make the change and to take a step towards a better model. It is a lot more involved than a few board members sitting in the room and making a decision to pay high salary to the Imam.

First, we need to realize that the issue intertwines with other major gaps in the average America Masjid; namely, governance issues and revenue development issues. Second, let’s examine what other communities of faith are doing in the US and what lessons can be learned.

I will address the second point first: The highest paid clergy in the US in 2011 were the Rabbis of the Jewish community. With some variation between reform and conservatives, nevertheless they are all in the top tear, along with the Latter Day Saints (Mormon Church); both groups highly hierarchal and very specific with their fund development model. Their average package (not salary) is in excess of $100,000. The Mormon Church is reported to have 55,000 missionaries and 14 Million members worldwide. Membership dues are 10% of one’s salary unless exceptions are granted under extreme circumstances. A very similar model is run by the Jewish community with the understanding they all do grant families who are really in need some exceptions, but a member who is not fully paid will not have access to all services, especially Holiday services. At the other extreme is the Catholic Church. The average package for Catholic clergy in 2011 was $31,000 (which is likely to translate to a monthly salary of $2,000.) The fund development model for the Catholic Church is also at the other extreme: completely voluntary and in some churches the “asking” is not even formalized and is very passive.

Now, I am not claiming we need to follow one extreme or the other. Actually the Muslim ummah is always supposed to seek the comfortable middle position (wasat). What I do advocate is establishing a structured fund development model that allows the average suburban Masjid to sustain (not just afford) a decent salary and benefit package for an Imam. The statistics on Masajid suggest 3 different types: The Mega Masjid (1000+ weekend worshipers), the middle of the line mostly suburban or smaller city Masjid (300 to 500 weekend worshipers), and a small town/village or startup Masjid (100+/- weekend worshippers). The majority of the Masajid fall in the middle category and the majority of Masjid-going Muslims in the US attend a middle size masjid. So, let’s keep the discussion focused on those. Brother Omar discussed the multi-million dollar buildings in his article. Any Masjid, that is not a Mega Masjid, planning a capital project over $2 million is definitely over-burdening the community with brick and mortar. This means they are not likely to be able to afford much in human resource expenses, program development, or volunteer development expenses. So, the building actually becomes the obstacle that prevents communities from funding elements that actually build communities.

Additionally, even though I do not recommend mandating membership for services, the mindset of “voluntary” membership must be introduced to communities, so worshippers can understand that they are the ones responsible for maintaining and developing the Masjid community. Immigrant Muslims need to shake off the mentality of someone else will do it – like the Awqaf Ministry government entity in many Muslim countries which will take care of the Masjid and will pay the imam salary. Allah (SWT) has given us the honor and empowered us to establish a house for His worship and that is the motivation to build our voluntary membership. No, we will not require 10%, or 5% or 2.5%, but we need to build the culture and expecting to pay our share, to have planned, systematic giving, and our individual hearts and level of Eeman will dictate that percentage. It is not a privilege for the wealthy; this is everyone’s privilege, regardless of the bracket of income. Tax season is the perfect time for all to commit to a certain share, to commit to make a sacrifice and to participate systematically. Once a community is successful in building sustainable financial commitments, providing a package for a resident scholar or Imam becomes more feasible. A midsize Masjid Imam package should not be less than $70K and depending on expectations and involvement with other education programs, should go up to $100K.

The element of respect has as much to do with the governance and administration of the organization as it does with the benefit package. The position of the Imam within the overall structure of the organization matters. The Imam should enjoy special status by the governing entity and the executive entity. That will trickle down to the community. If respect for the Imam is displayed by the community leaders, that will be followed by respect from the community at large. Respect should be communicated by inclusiveness in the decision making, and by genuinely empowering the imam. (More of governance issues in a separate paper to follow)

In summary, the first step is to fix our governance, develop a fund development model that can sustain a good package for a community Imam, and then define the role of the Imam clearly, and empower him in areas relevant to Islamic guidance, and support him by providing professional development opportunities.

 

Subscribe for Updates
Get our latest posts delivered directly to your inbox
Subscribe for Updates
Never miss a blog post again

Guest author for MuslimSI.com

GuestsGuest Post: How a Community Masjid Can Afford to Provide a Competitive Salary for its Imam

8 Comments on “Guest Post: How a Community Masjid Can Afford to Provide a Competitive Salary for its Imam”

  1. ahmed

    MashaAllah, great article by a Masjid board member.

    A couple of questions:

    – Most masajid already have yearly or many-times-yearly fundraisers. How will people react when told they should sign up for membership and participate in fundraisers?

    – Just based on the zakah requests masajid receive, I assume most people either don’t pay their zakah or send it overseas. If this is the case with zakah which is an obligation, how can we convince people to pay this membership fee?

    – How will this be promoted? Khutbahs? Special lectures on the masjid finances? Most masajid are reluctant to give out detailed financial information, if they distribute any information at all. If attendees start paying membership fees, they will require information about where their funds are going. It won’t be closed-eyes giving like it is with donations and fundraisers.

    – What about those who give more fees? Will they / should they have more say in the governance? Would somebody be able to essentially buy their way into leadership? Not that this doesn’t happen already, but I’m trying to see what safeguards can be in place.

    – What about those who travel often or attend many masajid on a regular basis? Some people don’t consider themselves belonging to any masjid; they just go to whatever masjid happens to be close.

    I’m not trying to poke holes in the proposal, just seeing what can work best for us bi idhnillah.

    was salaamu alaikum,

    1. ibn abee omar

      maybe if memberships help reduce the frequency of fundraisers 🙂 of course a lot of this depends on what stage a masjid is at. a masid done with construction can create a membership program that’s got enough built in to cover expenses + funds for future projects. this would limit fundraisers to just very special occassions only.

      people can be convinced when they see whats being provided. what i’ve personally noticed (limited observation), is the over 40 crowd donates the most to masjids. the under 40 crowd does donate, but to different causes, perhaps because the masajid arent serving their needs.

      safeguards will only come through transparency and social accountability. im personally convinced its the only way.

      1. Maher

        Could not agree more brother Omar. Transparency and accountability are the weakest links in most communities. It is a dynamic model. Once people know how funds are used and witness success they will jump on board.

    2. Maher

      Brother Ahmed.
      MashaaAllah you hit on every point we encountered in the past few years. For the record, I am not a board member but I do volunteer as a revenue director for a local masjid.
      Every community has to find and identify its priority and its capacity. To do this right it needs to be a long term commitment and someone or even a committee must be dedicated for revenue development.
      In our case it took 3 years to build the membership and now we have a little less than 1/2 of the families who attend Jumua committed. We hold one fund raiser every year. That event is dedicated to capital projects. Memebership fees weekly collections and net program fees fund operations and salary.
      We are now ready to hire a scholar and the package will likely be $70 to $90K.
      Of course we do not mandate membership and all services are available to all. Members know this is for supporting the masjid not for benefits. Actually in the first two years we did not call it membership but Masjid Suppoters Program to avoid this expectation of benefits. Our members do get early notice to sign up for programs and get to nominate board members.
      Again, every community needs to build the revenue devolopment model that fits its demographics and capacity and someone must be focused on just doing that and nothing else. I hope this helps. May Allah guide us all to what pleases Him best.

  2. WebEmDee

    MashaAllah. Excellent article. I’m glad we’re finally having this discussion here. I am a volunteer with a budding masjid project in my locality. Like many others, I agree with the idea of voluntary membership among the congregation, but I would love to see a case report (or a few case reports) that will prove the superiority of this method over others. Would you be kind enough to share some data with us so we can come to some sort of objective conclusion?

    Also, at your own masjid/center, did you start with membership drives from the first day or did that come later? I’m asking to see if we can have some sort of “before” and “after” picture in regards to membership drives?

    JazakAllah again for such a thought provoking post.

    WSalaam

  3. Www.Clickycoach.Com

    I do consider all of the ideas you’ve offered for your post. They are very convincing and can definitely work. Still, the posts are very quick for beginners. May you please lengthen them a bit from subsequent time? Thank you for the post.

  4. Tangri

    What’s Taking place i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It positively useful and it has aided me out loads. I’m hoping to give a contribution & aid other customers like its helped me. Great job.

  5. Abe

    I wilⅼ nott have ahyone in my life ѡhο is not supportive.
    Ԝhen it comeѕ tto accessories ⅼike this, the old advice “you get what you pay for” applies.
    Ӏ boat and yօur meet don’t means for rеadily
    moving yоur famjly belongings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *